Friday, February 1, 2013

Crowsnest Pass Branding Open House


Last night I attended the Open House for the unveiling of the new branding for our municipality. First let me say the old brand showing a miner with his hard hat and pick was much dated (unless Riversdale does bring mining back to the Pass) and stale and in need of an update.

Well we got that last night, or should I say the elite in our community did with an hour long presentation by the group who designed and show-cased our new brand and look to the community at a special invited guests only wine & hor d'oeuvres presentation. The rest of the community could be damned as the Open House for us which was from 6-8 p.m. consisted of eating the left-overs and fending for ourselves for what exactly our new brand was and why, with displays, handouts and a muted powerpoint presentation that ran on and on in a loop repeating the same message as our only resources to information on this new brand. No hour-long presentation for us, the peasants, who paid for this gala.

However the evening did allow me to socialize with many people in groups and in one-on-one's, including with respect to the latter for example, with our CAO Myron Thompson who I found to be both forthright and candid as usual, and open to answering many of my questions on recent issues. When I brought up the subject of communication (or lack of), that being, people here felt in the dark on much of what our leaders have been doing he admitted that was a problem but stated that much of that was due to the fact people do not go to the source when questioning things. His door, for example, is always open he assured me and he is always willing to answer peoples questions and deal with their concerns, if only people would contact him. Apparently few people do. That he says is part of the communication problem.

Had a lovely long chat with our CFO Marian Vanoni mainly about the new brand. Told her and Sasha JaegerBaird, who joined us, that I could have done that job in five minutes by merging the awesomely beautiful banner heading the municipality has on their Facebook page with the Community Futures 'Mountain Freedom' logo, and Voila! :-)

Sasha, on her blog, has done a pretty good job of a write up on this event as well as in a personal correspondence raising some interesting thoughts and questions with respect to "Other than the costs associated with doing the branding study and creating the new brand, what will the total costs be (to the taxpayers) to implement this brand and put it onto all the municipal vehicles, buildings and signs?"

I must say that I have to totally agree with Sasha that "Naturally Rewarding" does not stick in one's mind. My wife and I both have asked each other several times since yesterday, "what is the brand name, again? Got no problem with the new mountain peak logo but they should give serious consideration, I think, to changing "Naturally Rewarding" to "Mountain Freedom". Although I can see the mayor's view that after having taken away most of our "freedoms" that we should be constantly reminded about "rewarding" him. Speaking of which, Da Mare totally avoided me, even resorting to running to the back to talk with the kitchen help to get away from having a conversation with me. :-( As did the councillors there, although I did get a friendly greeting from Emile Saindon.

The bottom line in my mind with respect to this new Branding for our community is it looks good, but is not catchy and therefore fails to do the job it is intended to do. This is of course my personal opinion, others I spoke to liked it. But this could be due to too much wine. When they sober up today it might be a different story? Only kidding. :-)


For more on our new brand go here.


UPDATE: 16:30

Municipal Media Release on Branding




You are not who you once were, yet you're not the person (community) you are still becoming.

41 comments:

Anonymous said...

What is there natural about some multy coloured triangles. Looks like a Picaso abstract. Refreshing? would be if the Mare councel and administration suddenly vanished and we could FIX everything they screwed up and I mean everything.They will always be remembered as the most incompetend people ever put in charge of a Municipality.

Anonymous said...

John, The mountain freedom logo never had the miner with the pick.
I look at both logos and I can only say it was a waste of time and money.There was nothing wrong with mountain freedom.The new logo will not make us a better community in any way.It must be easy to spend other people's money.

Anonymous said...

As long as an arrogant, elitist entitlement attitude prevails in this community this mayor and council will continue to flounder. No common touch is their own undoing.

John Prince said...

Anon @12:58
'Mountain Freedom' was the brand and logo Community Futures came up with that I personally like very much. The newly replaced (as of last night) municipal logo with the miner and pike you can see here...

http://johnprince.ca/images/cnp_logo.gif

JP

Anonymous said...

I do not like it. There is nothing unique about "Naturally rewarding". Everywhere you go in Alberta, you can be "Naturally rewarded" from the badlands, to the wheat fields to the mountains of Banff and Jasper. How are you going to sell the Pass when literally everywhere you go you can be "natually rewarded". In addition, I think it is very limiting by ignoring one of our greatest strengths, the people and its history. Do you think Calgarians will be coming to the Pass to experience "mother nature" when they have the same thing right next door in Banff. Missed opportunity. At least "Mountain Freedom" has the potential to be developed into something unique. Pursue your passions in the Pass, whatever they may be. We do not have the restrictions the national parks do.From bird watching to snowmobiling, the Pass can do it all. Instead, they give us something very passive - naturally rewarding. Waste of money. They should have spent it developing "Mountain freedom".

Anonymous said...

I just about fell off my chair laughing when I read what Myron Thompson shamefully told you John,how he is there for the commoners and his door and ears are always open to listen to our woes. Has anyone ever tried to get hold of him. Good luck, and on weekends he hides in Sylvan Lake where I was told he lives. He just collects his paycheque here

Anonymous said...

John, Sorry I thought they were replacing mountain freedom which I like better also. It is time for a change from that miner and his pick.

Anonymous said...

Crowsnest Promoter:

New Crowsnest Pass brand announced

Anonymous said...

Read the Promoter on new Logo. Yes we will remember this artificial logo . We will always remember that it was forced on us by the worst administration ever. You are leaving a fitting memory. I hope you will be a memory SOON. The logo we are stuck with.

Anonymous said...

"The new brand reflects the experiences of visitors and residents as they interact with Crowsnest’s natural environment,”
...
"The colours in shades of blue, green and ivory are representative of peacefulness and nature ..."

The tagline, “Naturally Rewarding”, emphasizes the area’s natural environment and the rewarding lifestyle residents and visitors enjoy. The looping typeface of the tagline was selected as reminiscent of fly-fishing lines and swirling breezes."


Does anyone else think it's a bit ironic that next week they are staging a promotion for a private company proposing open pit mines around the community?

peter rosner said...

Somehow i feel less free than i did before this council changed the face of this community. I wonder do those peace officers promote the "Naturally Rewarding" theme when they are handing you your ticket. I guess it has been rewarding for the CEO and the Fire Chief and the deputy fire chief and so on and so on.

Anonymous said...

5:07.

Thanxs for bringiing up the irony here.

If "The colours in shades of blue, green and ivory are representative of peacefulness and nature ...", wouldn't the interiors of our prisons be painted in such colours?

"The looping typeface of the tagline was selected as reminiscent of fly-fishing lines"

No accomplished fly fisherman would understand that one, nor would anyonyone be enticed to take up fly fishing in the CNP because of this "looping typeface".

This is quite the promotional spin.

And I can hardly wait for the the colours, as promised, to appear, in order to calm me.

Anonymous said...

Personally I think that too much is given to the whole idea of 'branding'. Really....what's Calgary's 'brand'? Fernie? Lethbridge? Pincher?
I have no idea.

And personally, I think the triangles look stupid. I count more than 5 when I look at it. LOL
Only thing I like are the fonts. woohoo! Money well spent. ROFLMAO

Anonymous said...

With this new logo that is called branding Are we now their Cattle??????

Anonymous said...

Yes it is called cash cows

Anonymous said...

Calgary's brand is the Stampede, and the hat that comes with it. Our brand used to be Thunder in the Valley. That is what people talked about, the rest came with it. Mountain Freedom made some sense because it differentiated us from the other areas. Now we have no brand. Buying a logo from a logo shop does not brand make. Stampede was started by just a few people and it took many, many years before it became a brand. If anything, this council has damaged the little brand that we used to have.

Anonymous said...

Anon 7:28 said:
"Calgary's 'brand'?"
Here you go:
Pricey new Calgary slogan latest example of wasted words
Good rant. I'll just quote the punchline:
"Stop Wasting Taxpayer Money: if city council ever needed a new motto, that’s it."

Anonymous said...

Somehow it doesn't surprise me that the negative bloggers would find something to bitch about with our new brand. It never stops, does it?

Anonymous said...

What is negative about this fiasco?

Anonymous said...

Anon 10:31 said:
Somehow it doesn't surprise me that the negative bloggers would find something to bitch about with our new brand. It never stops, does it?

Please educate us on the benefits of the five triangles and "Naturally rewarding".

BTW, I notice there is no mention of Heritage in this thing. Does that mean the Museum, Alberta Provincial Police Barracks and Bellevue Mine are on the chopping block?

Anonymous said...

Anon 10:31 You must be a weekender and you do not have to put up with this crap until you visit here for a few days. Oh I forget the Mare is going to shmooze you.

Anonymous said...

10:31,

Tell us all how you recieved your invite to the party.

Anonymous said...

by invitation of course

Jose said...

"Mountain Freedom" stands head and shoulders above the new Brand. Naturally Rewarding simply does not have a retention factor nor a pleasing background.

Reading the comments above, it is obvious that there is a Let Them Eat Cake atitude within the Administration, and those in the inner circle are taunting the regular folk. Now that's a sure way to foster cooperation and support!

To have a reception for the inner circle for the Branding is insulting. We all pay taxes. To further separate the masses if the Riversdale reception is indeed going forward as indicated, is a sure way to have an opposition mounted against the project. Look for the enviro groups to get backing from strange bedfellows. These guys (promoters and Muni) heads are up their butts.

The Mayor, Council and Admimistration are slinging crap into the faces of the majority of Pass residents. Don't think for a moment they do not know what they are doing. Typical elitist politicians who forgot who voted them in.

Jose

Anonymous said...

Can anyone name the Elite who were invited before us commeners. Be quite interesting to know who NOT to vote for next time around .

Anonymous said...

1:52,

I don't have a list but one of the attendees would have been a certain councillor that said the increase in Franchise Fees would cost me only 25 cents more a day. (How nice that he knows my financial abilities) Now I have just paid $10 for this fiasco? And still he drinks the wine that I paid for without wishing my presence?

Yes, this is 'Animal Farm' deja-vu.

How arrogant!

Anonymous said...

Jose, in this: “Don't think for a moment they do not know what they are doing.” you are a bit wrong. When it comes to building public support for anything - THEY DO NOT KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING. And one should not jump to conclusions and blame the Australians for this backward attempt to build public support for their project. This arrangement is made by our municipal office which is trying hard to give itself a bigger role in the deal. The Australians are nice and go along with the charade because this is how business is done everywhere. It’s not nice to see grown men panting to get credit. This does not play very well anywhere, but especially not in the Crowsnest Pass.

Anonymous said...

7:17.


Sadly, it does.

Anonymous said...

I asked my daughter what she thought about the new brand. Her first impression was that it looked like a bunch of teepees. The blank space in the center she said looked like a door into the big teepee in the middle. She had a hard time even making out the word after "Naturally ....". She laughed when I told her it was Naturally Rewarding. She said the Pass was not Rewarding!! Then I tested her memory 3 minutes later. I asked her what it said again, all she could remember was something "... Rewarding". Obviously a big FAIL!!!

Anonymous said...

LOL Teepees!!

Anonymous said...

Anon 7:17 wrote:
"The Australians are nice and go along with the charade because this is how business is done everywhere."

I bet the Government of Mozambique didn't stage Riversdale promotional events in the Presidential Palace.

Anonymous said...

And does the goverment of Mozambique drink wine and dine on h'ordovers at the expense of the less fortunate? I may think so. Is it time to think deeply here, as to what is to occur if the proposed economic oppertunities proceed.

peter rosner said...

"All animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others"
After that it did not seem strange when next day the pigs who were supervising the work on the farm all carried whips in their trotters.

Anonymous said...

Anon. 9:36 – All I said was there is no need to dump on the Australians because our municipal office is totally inept when it comes to public relations. The Australians are professionals in this and I am sure if they had an opportunity to stage a first public open house they would have not made the mistake that our municipal office is doing. By being “nice,” it simply means they are not in the position to tell our top elected fella that he is not serving their cause by the awkward method of introducing them into the community. In a normal world, they would have had an open house for the entire community first, (no need to piss anyone off for no good reason), and after that they would have separate meetings with whoever they wanted. That way you keep peace in a small community. This is why in October, we have to get more capable people on council. This will be important because the next council gets elected for four years. We can’t suffer four more years of this Bureaucratic Empire Building and the wasting of taxpayer’s money.

Anonymous said...

It looks like Riversdale asked our municipal office for some input into their initial press release and then they appended it to the release. Embarrassing to see a grown man panting so hard for credit and recognition. We can expect more of this in the media portion of the meet and greet. This is why there is such an awkward schedule for the event.

Anonymous said...

It really looks like a sign for a campground.

Anonymous said...

Valid aurgument, but I am not camping here.

Anonymous said...

The problem I have with the new brand is, you can't read it on the flags, the font is not great for flags.

Anonymous said...

Looks like they killed our brand and bought us a logo. By invitation. Lame.

zig zigler said...

The brand should be a pic of some of the stores on main street with for lease signs in the windows.

John Prince said...

Check out the banner at the top left on the Chamber of Commerce website.

Not only are they in keeping with not having 'Crowsnest Pass' but simply 'Crowsnest' with what Community Futures have advocated for (Pass suggests a place to go through and not stop in) but they also have 'Mountain Freedom' in their logo.

This I believe is a much better fit for our community.

JP

Search This Blog

Loading...